Skip to content
Request a Demo
Explore products
Explore Solutions
Explore more from traild
Request a Demo

How Invoice Fraud Happens and Why It’s Hard to Catch

See how a payment redirection scam unfolds in AP, and why manual checks miss it.

An AP clerk receives a fraud alert email on her phone

U.S. businesses reported more than $3 billion in losses to business email compromise (BEC) in 2025. That’s at the national level for one country, but from the perspective of an individual business operating with already thin margins, any loss can be catastrophic, whether it’s $10,000 or $1 million.

Imagine a mid-size business supporting the real economy, like a manufacturing, distribution, or construction firm. Perhaps it’s family-owned, established for generations, with career-long employees and hundreds or thousands of happy, loyal customers. The idea that anyone would take advantage of their operations and intentionally defraud the business of hard-earned income might feel inconceivable.

“That could never happen to us” is an understandable assuagement, but the data on business fraud simply can’t be ignored.

Perhaps the best defense to business fraud is a proactive offense. And the first step in protecting your business from the detrimental effects of fraud is understanding how it happens and what you can do to secure potential risk vectors.

This post explains one prevalent form of business fraud: invoice fraud. Drawing on our experience in automated AP for global businesses in the real economy, we’ll explain how invoice fraud unfolds; how, where, and why it slips through well-run companies and their experienced, dutiful finance teams; and how to close those risk gaps.

What Is Invoice Fraud?

Invoice fraud is any scheme that gets a business to pay money it does not owe using a false, altered, or duplicated invoice. It takes six common forms:

  1. Fake supplier scams

  2. Insider scams

  3. Payment redirection

  4. Advance fee fraud

  5. Collusion

  6. Overbilling or duplicate invoices

Most cases are scams in the technical sense, because someone inside the business authorizes the payment. A busy AP clerk, working through a full queue, understandably overlooks a changed bank account on an invoice from a familiar, long-standing supplier. The clerk passes it to the next level of approval, and the CFO approves it out of the same familiarity and trust.

Once the business authorizes the payment, its recourse is limited after the money leaves the account. In the 2026 Signal B2B Finance Report, a CFO at a New York manufacturing company said, “Companies assume that their fraud insurance will cover them,” but getting a loss covered is harder than it sounds.

How Does Invoice Fraud Happen?

The scenario below is an illustrative composite, not a specific customer. It follows a payment redirection scam built on business email compromise (BEC), in which a fraudster poses as a trusted supplier or executive by email and persuades someone to send money or change payment details.

Fraud scenario:

  1. A fraudster researches a mid-sized manufacturer and one of its regular suppliers. Public profiles and a compromised supplier mailbox reveal the names, order rhythm, and tone of past emails. Generative AI now reproduces that tone convincingly.

  2. An email arrives from what appears to be the supplier’s accounts team. The supplier has changed banks, it says, and attaches an invoice with new account details.

  3. The invoice matches the usual amount and timing, so an AP clerk enters it and routes it for approval. The approver sees a familiar supplier, a plausible amount, and a clean routing history.

  4. The payment goes out with the next batch. The real supplier chases an unpaid invoice three weeks later, and the business learns the money went elsewhere.

Fake invoice fraud follows a similar logic. A fictitious supplier is set up in the ERP, then submits a run of small invoices that sit below the most rigorous approval thresholds. Each one looks routine, and together they add up.

How Is Insider Invoice Fraud Different From Outside Fraud?

Outside fraud arrives from an external bad actor. A spoofed email, an unfamiliar bank account, or a message that reads slightly off gives a careful team something to notice. Insider fraud offers no such signal, because the operator is a trusted employee who already holds legitimate access and knows how the process works.

In an insider fraud scenario, an employee with access to supplier records can set up a fictitious supplier or alter the bank details on a real one. They know the approval thresholds and keep each invoice below them.

Collusion is when an employee and an outside supplier work together to defraud the business. They inflate invoices, duplicate billings, or approve payments for work that was never done. One party sits inside the process and the other supplies convincing paperwork, so the amounts stay small and the invoices look routine. The loss builds slowly and often surfaces only in an audit.

Nothing in these cases looks foreign, so catching them depends on spotting behavior that departs from the norm, such as a new supplier with no registration record or a run of invoices that sit just under a threshold.

Why Is Invoice Fraud So Hard to Catch?

Only 44% of the finance leaders surveyed in the 2026 Signal B2B Finance Report are confident their company would detect a fraudulent payment before it leaves.

When a fraudster mirrors the routine AP process, every step seems legitimate. The email reads correctly, the invoice is formatted correctly, and the approval is recorded correctly. Nothing in the process asks, for example, whether the bank account is correct.

Fraudsters build for exactly this. Amounts stay under approval thresholds, timing follows the supplier’s real billing cycle, and generative AI now mimics an executive’s or supplier’s tone well enough to pass a quick read. An approval records that someone signed off. It cannot tell you whether the bank account belongs to the supplier.

Lean mid-market AP teams review invoices manually, at volume, under deadline. In the 2026 Signal survey, 58% of finance teams report verifying supplier bank details manually or with only very basic automation. For duplicate, error, and fraud detection, the figure is 72%. Understandably, detection quality suffers as volume rises, and controls such as phoning a supplier to confirm new bank details depend on someone remembering to make the call. In some scenarios, the fraudster even changes the phone number and verifies the fake bank details when called.

And remember, all these workflows occur in an ERP system that finance teams use continually and trust as the operational and logistics hub for orders, inventory, and payments. ERPs are not designed around the nuance of invoice fraud, particularly in complex, high-volume industries. Periodic audits and quarterly reviews add another layer of review, though they typically find problems after the payment has gone out, the money is gone, and the hit has been absorbed.

How Can Finance Teams Protect Their Business from Invoice Fraud Losses?

Protecting your business from invoice fraud means closing the gaps at three risk vectors: invoice ingestion, approval, and payment. Here’s how we do it at Traild:

  • Behavioral anomaly detection flags invoices and payment details that depart from each supplier’s normal behavior, including sudden bank account changes.

  • Supplier verification checks supplier details against government and tax registration data, flagging a fictitious supplier before it receives payment.

  • Duplicate invoice detection stops the same invoice from being paid twice.

  • Executive payment review gives a senior reviewer a final look at the batch before funds leave the business.

  • A full audit trail records who approved each invoice and when.

Together, these checks shift detection from the audit to the moment of the transaction, when the finance team still has time to act. Traild integrates deeply with your ERP, so your team keeps its workflow and gains protection without adding steps.

Ross Orchard, Finance Controller at Little Locals Early Learning, said:

“We’ve seen cases where suppliers’ emails get hacked and invoices come through with changed bank details. It’s good security knowing that Traild flags when something doesn’t match what’s in the system. Traild automates the kind of checks that you’d just never have time or be able to do manually.”

Finance Advice for Finance Teams Fearful of Invoice Fraud

Start by mapping where your process verifies a supplier’s bank details and who owns that check. If the answer depends on one person remembering to make a call, the control has a gap.

Protect what you’ve built by checking every invoice before it reaches the payment run.

If invoice fraud keeps you up at night, or you have already been targeted, contact our team at Traild to learn how we can help.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Are the Warning Signs of a Fraudulent Invoice?

A bank account that differs from the supplier’s records is the clearest warning sign. Others include a new supplier with no registration history, an email domain that differs slightly from the usual one, amounts just under an approval threshold, and urgent requests to skip the normal process. Any one of these deserves a second look before payment.

Can You Recover Money Paid on a Fraudulent Invoice?

Recovery is difficult once funds have moved, so speed matters. Contact your bank immediately to request a recall, and report the incident to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center. Banks often treat these payments as authorized, which limits what they can reverse.